Love over faith
The film Silent Love, directed by Eiji Uchida, features two protagonists with disabilities: Mika (Minami Hamabe) is a pianist who becomes blind after a traffic accident, and Aoi (Ryosuke Yamada) is mute due to a throat injury from saving a friend. Their lives intersect when Aoi rescues Mika from a suicide attempt; they reconnect later at the music college where she studies.
The film fits into a known romantic‑melodramatic Japanese tradition of “star‑crossed lovers,” with obstacles like illness or disability adding emotional weight. There are moments of genuine feeling in their struggle — the grief, the dependency, the longing — that could touch audiences.
Over‑reliance on tropes and clichés: The reviewer argues the plot leans heavily into familiar melodramatic devices (blindness, muteness, sacrifice, class differences, gangster elements) without bringing enough new nuance or depth. Uneven tone: At times the film veers abruptly into more sensational or genre‑film territory (gangster conflicts, violence) that feel grafted on rather than organically arising from earlier emotional setup. This shift can feel jarring.
Characters lacking complexity: The reviewer suggests that the lead characters are somewhat stereotypical, and their struggles — while serious — aren’t always portrayed with enough internal conflict or surprising moral choices that might make them more compelling. Believability concerns: Some plot points or character decisions stretch plausibility — especially how quickly things escalate into violence or criminal entanglements, or how certain sacrifices are portrayed. These moments pull the film away from emotional authenticity into melodramatic excess.
.jpeg)
0 Comments